Italian Steak Sandwich


Thin slices of frizzled beef, melted cheese and a bun that is crispy on the outside and soft and tender on the inside, are the quintessential ingredients of this famous sandwich.

Created in Philadelphia by two brothers from Abruzzi, Italy, this sandwich is known as a Philly Cheese Steak (or just Cheese Steak if you’re from Philadelphia).

In 1930, twenty-five year old, Pasquali “Pat” Olivieri, opened a hot dog stand to serve the lunch crowd in the area. Wishing to offer something other than hot dogs, Pat sent his brother, Harry, to the local butcher for steak, fried it on his hot dog grill and this Philadelphia cultural icon was born.

It wasn’t until 1949, that an idea from an employee to add cheese, turned this into the Cheese Steak. In 1952, when “Cheese Wiz” (canned cheese sauce) was created, it was so popular that it became the topping for this steak sandwich.

The Olivieri’s weren’t the only Italian immigrants to make a name for themselves by creating a sandwich. In 1906, Sicilian, Salvatore Lupo, opened Central Grocery in New Orleans, home of the famous Muffuletta.

And in 1965, a young man (17 years old) opened his first sandwich shop in Bridgeport, Connecticut. Nine years later, that shop had evolved into sixteen others throughout the state. Today, that simple sandwich shop started by young Fred DeLuca, seems to be as prevalent as Starbucks. Perhaps you’ve seen them … they are called Subway.


  • 1 1/2 pounds rib eye steak, boneless
  • 2 yellow onions, chopped
  • olive oil (for frying)
  • 8 ounces Cheese Wiz, American or provolone (I actually used fontina)
  • 4 Hoagie-style rolls
  • pepperoncini, optional
  1. Freeze the steak 45 minutes to make slicing easier.
  2. Slice meat into 1/4-thick slices, set aside.
  3. In a large saute pan, cook the onions in a bit of the oil until caramelized, season with salt and pepper. Remove from pan.
  4. In the same pan, on medium-high heat, warm a little oil, season the steak with salt and pepper, cook quickly (1-2 minutes) until nicely browned. Remove to a cutting board, cut into smaller strips.
  5. Return meat and onions to pan, reheat.
  6. Crisp the buns in a 350* oven for a few minutes.
  7. If using American or provolone, open the buns, line it with slices of cheese, then top with the hot meat and onion mixture (the cheese melts and melds the whole thing into deliciousness). If you’re using the Cheese Wiz, place the meat on the bun, then top with the sauce (less is more).
  8. Top with pepperoncini if desired.

This recipe makes four Cheese Steaks. We ate two, wrapped the other two in foil, refrigerated them for later. They can be reheated in a 350* oven.

We gobbled up our Cheese Steaks before I could take a picture. This picture is of a sandwich that I was wrapping for later, so I let the meat cool before spooning it on top of the cheese. Once you reheat it, allowing the meat and cheese to meld together, it transforms into the meat-y, cheese-y melted goodness this sandwich is famous for.

Lemon Sorbet with Candied Basil
Chocolate Espresso Olive Oil Cake